U-Haul vs Penske vs Budget: Which Moving Truck Rental Is Best?

Last updated: October 8, 2026

In the U-Haul vs Penske vs Budget comparison, U-Haul usually wins on convenience and local moves thanks to its 25,000+ locations, Penske stands out for long one-way moves because its one-way rentals include unlimited mileage, and Budget is a strong option when its advertised discounts apply to you. This guide compares locations, truck sizes, one-way policies, pricing models, discounts, truck condition and roadside support, plus Enterprise and Home Depot as alternatives.

Key Takeaways
  • U-Haul lists 25,000+ rental locations in the US and Canada; Penske has roughly 2,500+ and Budget roughly 1,600+ (counts vary by source).
  • Penske advertises unlimited mileage on one-way rentals. U-Haul and Budget one-way quotes include a set mileage allowance, with charges beyond it.
  • Penske advertises 12% off for AAA members and 15% off for military; Budget advertises up to 20% off for AARP members plus military, student and first-responder programs.
  • U-Haul does not list a standing nationwide AAA, military or student discount; savings come from promotions and location-level offers.
  • Enterprise and Home Depot rent trucks mainly for local, round-trip jobs, not one-way moves.

On this page:

U-Haul vs Penske vs Budget: how do they compare?

The three companies rent similar box trucks to do-it-yourself movers, but they differ in network size, how they charge for miles, and which discounts they publish. The table below summarizes each company’s own published information as of October 2026, supplemented by independent reviews where noted.

FeatureU-HaulPenskeBudget
Rental locations25,000+ (US and Canada)About 2,500+ (US and Canada)About 1,600+ in the continental US (some sources cite more)
Vehicle sizesPickup, cargo van, 10, 15, 20, 26 and 29 ft trucksCargo van, 12, 16, 22 and 26 ft trucksCargo van, 12, 16 and 26 ft trucks (24 ft at some locations)
One-way rentalsYes, very wide coverageYesYes
Miles on one-waySet allowance included in quoteUnlimited (advertised)Set allowance; extra miles charged
In-town pricingBase rate (from $19.95) plus per-mile chargeDaily rate plus per-mile chargeDaily rate plus per-mile charge
Advertised discountsPromotions and location offers; no standing AAA/military/student discount listedAAA 12%, military 15%, student programAARP up to 20%; military, student, police/fire/EMT, motor club programs
Roadside assistanceIncluded with all truck rentals24/7, included24-hour emergency line; extended coverage optional
Fleet reputationMixed; vans and pickups cycled every 12–24 monthsKnown for a newer, well-maintained fleetMixed; varies by location
Best forLocal moves, small loads, rural areas, truck plus storageLong one-way moves, renters who want newer trucksRenters who qualify for AARP or other listed discounts

Which company has the most locations?

U-Haul has by far the largest network, with more than 25,000 rental locations across the US and Canada according to uhaul.com. That count includes company-owned centers and independent dealers such as hardware stores and gas stations, which is why U-Haul is often the only option in small towns.

Penske has more than 2,500 consumer truck rental locations in the US and Canada, many of them dedicated rental centers or partner stores. Budget’s fact sheet lists more than 1,600 corporate and dealer locations in the continental US, while other sources cite figures from about 1,700 to 2,800 depending on what they count. In practice, both are well covered in metro areas and thinner in rural ones.

More locations matter most for one-way drop-offs: the closer the return point to your new home, the less you drive an empty truck.

What truck sizes does each company offer?

All three cover the full range from a cargo van to a 26 ft truck. U-Haul offers the most steps in between, plus pickups, and lists a 29 ft truck on its truck rental page.

Home size (approx.)U-HaulPenskeBudget
Studio or small loadCargo van or 10 ftCargo van or 12 ftCargo van or 12 ft
1–2 bedrooms15 ft16 ft16 ft
2–3 bedrooms20 ft16 ft or 22 ft16 ft or 24 ft
3–4+ bedrooms26 ft (29 ft for larger homes)22 ft or 26 ft24 ft or 26 ft

These pairings follow each company’s own room guidance and are approximate. Not every size is available at every location. For U-Haul specifically, our truck size guide walks through what fits in each truck.

One practical difference: U-Haul says its trucks run on unleaded gasoline and have low loading decks, while independent reviews note Penske’s 22 ft and 26 ft trucks use diesel. Diesel often costs more per gallon, so factor fuel into long-distance comparisons.

Which is best for a one-way, long-distance move?

For long one-way moves, get quotes from all three, but give Penske a close look because its website advertises unlimited mileage on one-way rentals. U-Haul and Budget include a mileage allowance based on your route and charge for miles beyond it.

  • Penske: one-way rentals (trips over 25 miles) include unlimited mileage, per Penske’s moving truck page. Extra days are still charged.
  • U-Haul: one-way pricing is typically a flat rate that already includes a set number of days and miles. Extra miles and days cost more.
  • Budget: one-way quotes include estimated days and miles. Budget’s fact sheet lists extra miles at $0.70 each if bought before pickup and $0.85 at or after pickup, and purchased miles are non-refundable.

Unlimited mileage only saves money if you would otherwise exceed the allowance, for example with a detour or a long drive to the drop-off. On a direct route, a cheaper base quote with an allowance can still win. Quotes also swing by direction: routes out of high-demand areas cost more with every company. Our guide to one-way vs in-town rentals explains how those quotes are built.

U-Haul publishes its own sample comparison: in January 2026 quotes for a 26 ft truck from Dallas to Orlando, it listed U-Haul at $2,588.30, Penske at $2,985.40 and Budget at $3,164.87, truck only. Treat that as one route on one date, published by U-Haul, not a general rule.

How does in-town pricing compare?

For local moves, all three use the same basic model: a rate for the rental period plus a charge for every mile driven. U-Haul advertises in-town rentals starting at $19.95; Penske and Budget quote a daily rate plus mileage that varies by location and truck size.

The headline rate rarely decides the total. Mileage, fuel, coverage, taxes and environmental or other fees can add far more than the difference between base rates. A short move with many trips favors the company with the lowest per-mile charge; a single trip across a metro area depends more on the base rate. See how much it costs to rent a U-Haul for a full breakdown.

What discounts do U-Haul, Penske and Budget advertise?

Penske and Budget both publish membership and affiliation discounts on their websites; U-Haul relies mainly on promotions and location-level offers. The table lists only programs shown on each company’s site as of October 2026.

Discount typeU-HaulPenskeBudget
AAANo nationwide program listed12% off rentals and suppliesMotor club program (details on site)
AARPNo national program foundNot shown on main moving pageUp to 20% off
MilitaryNo national program found15% offProgram listed
StudentsNo national program foundProgram listedProgram listed
First respondersNo national program foundNot shown on main moving pagePolice, fire and EMT program
Storage tie-inOne month free storage with a one-way rental at participating locationsNoneNone

Budget notes that online discounts generally cannot be combined with other discounted rates or offers, and every company’s terms change. Read the conditions before you book. For U-Haul, our ways to save on a U-Haul truck rental covers options beyond discounts.

How do truck condition, roadside help and fees compare?

Penske has the strongest reputation for newer trucks, while U-Haul and Budget reviews are more mixed and depend heavily on the location. All three provide a roadside assistance line for breakdowns.

  • Penske describes its fleet as among the newest in the industry and advertises free 24/7 roadside assistance, 365 days a year.
  • U-Haul says all truck rentals come with roadside assistance, its cargo vans and pickups are cycled out every 12–24 months, and returned vehicles are inspected before the next rental. Its optional Safetrip add-on (from about $5 per rental) covers items like lockouts and jump starts.
  • Budget runs a 24-hour emergency roadside line. Its optional Extended Roadside Assistance covers flat tires, lockouts and jump starts; without it, those services cost extra.

Fees differ too. Budget’s fact sheet lists a $150 average deposit and a $150 fee for cancellations with under 48 hours’ notice or no-shows. U-Haul’s reservations carry a $50 guarantee under specific conditions. Inspect any truck before you leave the lot, photograph existing damage, and check the fuel level against the contract.

Should you consider Enterprise or Home Depot instead?

Enterprise and Home Depot are worth a look for short, local jobs, but neither is built for one-way household moves.

  • Enterprise Truck Rental has close to 600 truck locations, and only some rent box trucks (roughly 15 to 26 ft). Trucks generally return to the original location, and renters pay a per-mile charge on top of the base rate.
  • Home Depot rents pickups, cargo vans and some box trucks from stores, with low rates for the first 75 minutes (its Load ‘N Go option). It does not offer one-way rentals itself; one-way moves are routed through its Penske partnership.

Both work well for hauling a couch across town or a load of materials, not for moving a household to another city.

How do you choose the right company for your move?

Get three quotes for the same truck size, dates and route, then compare full totals rather than base rates. That single step settles most comparisons.

  1. Pick the truck size first, so you compare like for like (a 15 ft U-Haul against a 16 ft Penske or Budget).
  2. Quote the same pickup date and drop-off city with each company.
  3. Check included days and miles, and the price of extras.
  4. Add estimated fuel, coverage, taxes and fees.
  5. Apply any discount you genuinely qualify for and read its terms.
  6. Check pickup and drop-off locations against your addresses and their hours.
Where people get this wrong: comparing a U-Haul 15 ft truck quote against a Penske 22 ft quote, or a one-way allowance against unlimited miles, without adjusting. Sizes are not identical across brands, and “unlimited miles” only matters if you would exceed the allowance. Line up equal capacity, equal dates and real mileage before you decide.

Timing changes every quote, whichever company you choose. Read about the best time to rent a U-Haul before locking in a date.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is U-Haul cheaper than Penske?

It depends on the move. U-Haul is often competitive for local moves and smaller trucks, while Penske’s unlimited mileage on one-way rentals can make it cheaper on long routes. Prices are set by location and date, so compare full quotes for your route.

Does Penske really include unlimited miles?

Penske advertises unlimited mileage on one-way rentals over 25 miles. Local rentals returned to the same location are charged per mile, and extra days on any rental cost more.

Does U-Haul offer a AAA or military discount?

U-Haul does not list a standing nationwide AAA, military or student discount on its website. Some independent dealers may offer their own deals, and U-Haul runs promotions, so check current offers and terms before booking.

Which company has the newest trucks?

Penske has the strongest reputation for a newer, well-maintained fleet. U-Haul cycles out its cargo vans and pickups every 12 to 24 months, while its box trucks and Budget’s fleet vary more by location.

Can I rent a one-way truck from Enterprise or Home Depot?

Generally no. Enterprise trucks usually return to the original location, and Home Depot sends one-way customers to its Penske partnership. Both are better suited to local jobs.

Going With U-Haul?

Check current U-Haul deals and their terms before you book, and estimate your total so you can compare quotes fairly.

Sources: U-Haul truck rentals, U-Haul one-way comparison, Penske moving truck rental, Budget Truck Rental, Penske Truck Leasing (Wikipedia), HireAHelper, U-Pack on Enterprise, This Old House on Home Depot. Policies and prices change; confirm with each company.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top